Jesse Merrill, founder of Good Culture. Photo: Harmon Li

Good morning and welcome to a Saturday edition of Inc.’s 1 Smart Business Story! Today, we have an interview with a CEO who recently sold a majority stake in his company for a ton of money. What’s that like?

Jesse Merrill founded Good Culture, a cottage cheese brand, a little over a decade ago in a few dozen Whole Foods doors. The Austin-based company was premised on the notion that the dairy aisle, beyond yogurt, was long overdue for innovation and new brand thinking. Good Culture now offers not only cottage cheese but also sour cream and cream cheese. As Kevin J. Ryan reports for Inc., Merrill wasn’t looking to take on a majority partner per se, but was open to a strategic investor who had a “good track record in growing brands from our scale to something much bigger.”

As Good Culture’s revenue passed the $200 million mark, interest from potential investors heated up, and Merrill couldn’t help but contemplate just how big the company might get.

In this story, you’ll discover:

  • What Merrill’s thought process was in determining when the right time was to sell

  • Why one private equity player stood out from the crowd

  • What the timeline for deal negotiations looked like

After a Personal Health Crisis, He Built a $500 Million Cottage Cheese Empire. Here’s How He Sold It

Jesse Merrill attracted over a half a billion dollars for his cottage cheese and dairy brand—without sacrificing his company’s culture.

Jesse Merrill was reading the ingredients in cottage cheese one morning when he had an epiphany. The product was high in protein and low in sugar, but loaded with preservatives and thickeners. Since he’d learned he had ulcer­ative colitis, Merrill paid close attention to what he ate and how it made him feel. To him, it seemed like many dairy products hadn’t innovated since the ’70s, a decade during which Americans ate twice as much cottage cheese as yogurt. He posited that, with a refresh, the category could regain the luster of its heyday.

Merrill founded Austin-based Good Culture in 2015, launching in a few dozen Whole Foods stores that year. The com­pany, which makes cottage cheese, cream cheese, and sour cream with no artificial ingredients, hit $200 million in annual revenue by 2025, when it sold a majority stake to L Catterton—a private equity firm that has acquired and scaled food brands including Odwalla and Kodiak Cakes—in a deal valuing it at over $500 million. Merrill, who remains the company’s CEO, recently spoke with Inc. about what the deal has meant for his company and its employees.

Kevin Ryan: How did the conversations with L Catterton start?

Jesse Merrill: We had a lot of inbound interest from several firms. It started to heat up about two years ago, to the point that it was hard to ignore. We decided to bring in the Los Angeles-based investment bank Houlihan Lokey to help us take those calls and hear them out. If it felt like it was something meaningful and compelling, then we would have deeper conversations. We were in talks with L Catterton for 18 to 24 months before we started talking numbers, so they put a lot of time into fostering a relationship. It wasn’t, “We want to buy you, so send us your financials and let’s figure this out.” It was much more relationship-­oriented, which I really loved.

How did you know they were the right partner?

As we started to have these conversations, we decided that, first and foremost, a firm needed to have a good track record in growing brands from our scale to something much bigger. That was table stakes. For me, the bigger side was the ­human side. I wanted to ensure that I felt energized by these people, that if I was going to stay on as the CEO, I would want to wake up ­every day and run through walls for these folks. And I wanted to ­ensure their values were aligned with mine. Over time, we narrowed it down to a few different groups that we really liked. We started to have more seri­ous conversations with L Catterton and got to a place where we were comfortable sharing more infor­ma­tion, and that ultimately led to their putting in a bid. 

What were the negotiations like?

Because L Catterton had put in the time to build the rapport with me, it didn’t feel like an overly clinical process. They were very human, very open, very casual. We didn’t actually start talking about numbers until the middle of December, and we closed the deal on February 2. It was a very compressed time frame because we’d been in conversations with them for 18-plus months.

What does this deal change for your company?

We love L Catterton’s resources and what they can do. Our revenue was a direct reflection of capac­ity—our out-of-stock metrics and insights from retailers showed us we were supplying less than 50 percent of our demand. L Catterton had the ability to bring in relationships across manufacturing, marketing, people, and culture. All those things are incredibly impor­tant to us as we think about scaling to the next level. Now they’re meeting with all of our department heads to ensure everybody has what they need. If there are any gaps, they’re helping fill them as quickly as they possibly can. We just hired a chief people officer. They helped us source that candidate within a few weeks, which normally would have taken a lot longer with a recruiter.

Growing a business for nearly a decade and then selling a majority stake must be bittersweet. How does it feel to no longer have control of the company?

It felt strange at first. This has been my baby. We did have other private equity partners take sizable ownership stakes in the company along the way, but this was certainly a new dynamic. Still, it felt right on the basis of where we want to be tomorrow. And nothing has changed from a cultural standpoint. I don’t wake up every day feeling like I report to some big entity. We still have that entrepreneurial magic. If anything, L Catterton leans into it. They want to foster my vision and help provide the resources I need to continue climbing to the top of the mountain.

5 More Smart Business Stories:

Stop spending more time double-checking your books than growing your business. BELAY provides the financial clarity and "peace of mind" you need to lead with confidence. Get your time back today. Get the Free Guide